Torreon: Gov’t cannot use R.A. 9851 to justify Dela Rosa’s surrender to ICC

Lawyer Israelito Torreon, legal counsel of Senator Ronald “Bato” dela Rosa, cautioned that the government cannot invoke Section 17 of Republic Act No. 9851, or the Philippine Act on Crimes Against International Humanitarian Law, as a legal ground to surrender the senator to the International Criminal Court (ICC).

Torreon’s statement came following reports that the ICC has allegedly issued a warrant of arrest and a diffusion order against Dela Rosa in connection with the Duterte administration’s anti-illegal drugs campaign. Dela Rosa served as Chief of the Philippine National Police (PNP) from July 2016 to April 2018.

He underscored that Section 17 of R.A. 9851 cannot be applied without due process, a valid extradition treaty, or judicial authorization. According to him, the provision is “not self-executing” and must conform to existing extradition laws—specifically Presidential Decree No. 1069 and the Supreme Court’s Rules on Extradition Proceedings—which require court oversight before any Filipino citizen can be turned over to a foreign or international tribunal.

“Hindi puwedeng gamitin ng gobyerno ang Section 17 ng R.A. 9851 para basta na lang isuko si Senator Dela Rosa sa ICC. Walang kapangyarihan ang Executive branch na gawin ‘yan nang walang utos ng korte o valid na proseso ng extradition,” Torreon said.

He added that the Philippines’ withdrawal from the Rome Statute in 2019 effectively ended its treaty obligations to cooperate with the ICC, making any act of compliance purely voluntary and not legally binding.

Torreon warned that enforcing an ICC warrant without judicial recognition would constitute executive overreach since the ICC is no longer a tribunal the Philippines recognizes.

“Ang paggamit ng Section 17 bilang basehan ng pagsuko sa ICC ay walang bisa sa ilalim ng Konstitusyon at walang batayan sa batas. Hindi puwedeng sundin ng gobyerno ang korte na hindi na natin kinikilala, lalo na kung lalabagin nito ang ating mga proteksyon sa Saligang Batas,” he stressed.